Mullins
Hoctor
Oakley
Franks
Rory Hannify
Claffey
browne
Cordial
Molloy
Cassidy
Brady
G Hanniffy
Carroll
Hanrahan
Murphy
Im aware that this team has it faults. All county teams need a half forward line to compete on puckouts and thats why ive gone with a dubious line. Hanniffy and Browne are needed n the backs cause the county is lacking in big strong pacey backsmen
Offaly hurlers 2006
- ballymanabroad
- All Star
- Posts: 181
- Joined: Thu Mar 03, 2005 10:37 pm
- Location: Rathfarnham
- Rynaghs Biffo
- All Star
- Posts: 538
- Joined: Thu Jul 14, 2005 4:23 pm
- Location: St. Kilda, Melbourne
1. Mullins
2. Hoctor
3. Oakley
4. Franks
5. K Brady
6. R Hanniffy
7. Claffey
8. Cordial
9. Browne
10. Murphy
11. J Brady
12. G Hanniffy
13. Carroll
14. Hanrahan
15. Murray
A Strong team, but still not up to standard. we need as good a team playing in the league week in week out, with the birr lads more than likely missing due to club championship, this could prove costly. Feels weird for me picking a team with no Rynaghs fellas on it, how times have changed.....
2. Hoctor
3. Oakley
4. Franks
5. K Brady
6. R Hanniffy
7. Claffey
8. Cordial
9. Browne
10. Murphy
11. J Brady
12. G Hanniffy
13. Carroll
14. Hanrahan
15. Murray
A Strong team, but still not up to standard. we need as good a team playing in the league week in week out, with the birr lads more than likely missing due to club championship, this could prove costly. Feels weird for me picking a team with no Rynaghs fellas on it, how times have changed.....
-
- All Star
- Posts: 587
- Joined: Sun Sep 25, 2005 2:59 pm
- Location: kilcullen
- Lone Shark
- All Star
- Posts: 5378
- Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2004 5:21 pm
- Club: Ferbane
- Location: Roscommon
- Contact:
My full analysis is going up in a few minutes, but for what it's worth - I think Joe Brady has to be picked. He's improving as a CB and was written off too quickly I reckon. Cleary has to start, he's been too good not to.
Mullins
Franks
Oakley
Cleary
Rory Hanniffy
Joe Brady
Teehan
Diggy
Barry Whelahan
Carroll
Gary Hanniffy
Browne
Lee
Hanrahan
Murphy
Subs:
O'Connor, Kealey, Rigney, Claffey, David Kenny, Hayden, O'Hara, Bergin.
Mullins
Franks
Oakley
Cleary
Rory Hanniffy
Joe Brady
Teehan
Diggy
Barry Whelahan
Carroll
Gary Hanniffy
Browne
Lee
Hanrahan
Murphy
Subs:
O'Connor, Kealey, Rigney, Claffey, David Kenny, Hayden, O'Hara, Bergin.
1 Brian Mullins
2 Kevin Brady
3 Paul Cleary
4 Brendan O'Meara
5 Barry Teehan
6 Rory Hanniffy
7 Niall Claffey
8 Gary Hanniffy
9 Stephen Browne
10 Brendan Murphy
11 Ger Oakley
12 Diggy Cordial
13 Aidan Hanrahan
14 Joe Bergin
15 Brian Carroll
Panel: Shane O'Connor, Eoin Kennedy or Damien McDermott, Fearghal Keeley, J.P.O'Meara, Eamonn Lee, Joe Brady, Damien Murray, James Rigney, Alan Egan, Andrew McRedmond, Daniel Hoctor, Ciaran Slevin, David Franks, Stephen Delaney, Mick O'Hara, Pat McIntyre, Colm Cassidy, Dylan Hayden, Michael Dwane.
2 Kevin Brady
3 Paul Cleary
4 Brendan O'Meara
5 Barry Teehan
6 Rory Hanniffy
7 Niall Claffey
8 Gary Hanniffy
9 Stephen Browne
10 Brendan Murphy
11 Ger Oakley
12 Diggy Cordial
13 Aidan Hanrahan
14 Joe Bergin
15 Brian Carroll
Panel: Shane O'Connor, Eoin Kennedy or Damien McDermott, Fearghal Keeley, J.P.O'Meara, Eamonn Lee, Joe Brady, Damien Murray, James Rigney, Alan Egan, Andrew McRedmond, Daniel Hoctor, Ciaran Slevin, David Franks, Stephen Delaney, Mick O'Hara, Pat McIntyre, Colm Cassidy, Dylan Hayden, Michael Dwane.
- Bord na Mona man
- All Star
- Posts: 4044
- Joined: Fri Nov 05, 2004 11:34 am
- Club: Clara
I would put Paul Cleary at full back. I think Ger Oakley was getting caught out by high balls this year. Cleary looks like a specialised full back. I would also be interested to see how Brendan O'Meara or Trevor Corcoran would get on at corner back. I haven't seen much of them, but they seem fairly dogged and diligent defenders.
I'd give Paul Molloy a run at midfield also. I don't think he would make it as a forward, but midfield might suit his game better. His use of possession and ability to stick over the odd score might improve us here.
I think in the long term, we need to find more aggressive players in the backs. We shouldn't make any apologies for playing spoilers and stoppers.
Kilkenny's defence started to leak like ours once it was without the slash hooking and briarcutting of Noel Hickey.
Cork have one of the niggliest corner backs around in Brian Murphy (far more intimidating than the Rock). It's time to start casting the net a bit wider to find timber merchants.
In Offaly we have tended to pick good all rounders in the backs - Cassidy, the Bradys, Teehan etc.
I'd be more interested in trying to dig out specialised players for positions.
Ollie Canning was an average Galway forward, thrown in at corner back as a desperation measure back in 2001 and look what became of him. Maybe there's a couple of unmined gems in Offaly?
To be fair to John McIntyre, he seems imaginative and isn't afraid to change things about (Kevin Kilmurray take note). Aidan Hanrahan as a full forward for example was a good move - that a more cautious manager mightn't have tried.
I'm certain that the sum of all parts that we have seen recently from our hurlers is far less than the collective ability.
I'd give Paul Molloy a run at midfield also. I don't think he would make it as a forward, but midfield might suit his game better. His use of possession and ability to stick over the odd score might improve us here.
I think in the long term, we need to find more aggressive players in the backs. We shouldn't make any apologies for playing spoilers and stoppers.
Kilkenny's defence started to leak like ours once it was without the slash hooking and briarcutting of Noel Hickey.
Cork have one of the niggliest corner backs around in Brian Murphy (far more intimidating than the Rock). It's time to start casting the net a bit wider to find timber merchants.
In Offaly we have tended to pick good all rounders in the backs - Cassidy, the Bradys, Teehan etc.
I'd be more interested in trying to dig out specialised players for positions.
Ollie Canning was an average Galway forward, thrown in at corner back as a desperation measure back in 2001 and look what became of him. Maybe there's a couple of unmined gems in Offaly?
To be fair to John McIntyre, he seems imaginative and isn't afraid to change things about (Kevin Kilmurray take note). Aidan Hanrahan as a full forward for example was a good move - that a more cautious manager mightn't have tried.
I'm certain that the sum of all parts that we have seen recently from our hurlers is far less than the collective ability.
Railway Cup Line-up
I notice that Leinster played Rory Hanniffy at right half-back in the "Sid" position, similar to Lone Shark's proposed Offaly team.
They had Gary Hanniffy at full-forward scoring 1-2 (where he spent some time in the county final) and Brian Carroll at No. 15 (0-2).
I still prefer Gary Hanniffy at midfield for the county but full forward would be better in my opinion than half forward where he just gets bottled up.
As Bord na Mona Man says Paul Molloy might be worth a look at midfield - he's maybe not an All-Star forward and not a specialist defender but he would chip in a few points from midfield.
John McIntyre does seem to be creative with trying players in different positions so I hope that he sticks with the lessons he learnt last year rather than re-learning them again during the course of embarrassing championship defeats.
Just to summarise again we finished up with:
Gary Hanniffy at midfield.
Barry Teehan in the half back line (much better there)
Paul Cleary a first team regular when fit ( I think he's better at full back)
Diggy in the half forwards rather than midfield.
Rory Hanniffy at centre half back
Ger Oakley question mark at full back after being replaced by Joe Brady with a few minutes to go due to problems under high ball against Dublin - I'd prefer to see him at centre-half forward
Aidan Hanrahan a first team regular
Damien Murray starting position in doubt although good squad player
Kevin Brady at corner back (not perfect yet but big & strong)
They had Gary Hanniffy at full-forward scoring 1-2 (where he spent some time in the county final) and Brian Carroll at No. 15 (0-2).
I still prefer Gary Hanniffy at midfield for the county but full forward would be better in my opinion than half forward where he just gets bottled up.
As Bord na Mona Man says Paul Molloy might be worth a look at midfield - he's maybe not an All-Star forward and not a specialist defender but he would chip in a few points from midfield.
John McIntyre does seem to be creative with trying players in different positions so I hope that he sticks with the lessons he learnt last year rather than re-learning them again during the course of embarrassing championship defeats.
Just to summarise again we finished up with:
Gary Hanniffy at midfield.
Barry Teehan in the half back line (much better there)
Paul Cleary a first team regular when fit ( I think he's better at full back)
Diggy in the half forwards rather than midfield.
Rory Hanniffy at centre half back
Ger Oakley question mark at full back after being replaced by Joe Brady with a few minutes to go due to problems under high ball against Dublin - I'd prefer to see him at centre-half forward
Aidan Hanrahan a first team regular
Damien Murray starting position in doubt although good squad player
Kevin Brady at corner back (not perfect yet but big & strong)