clubman wrote:cant blame tom coffey for that ,think there was a lot added to it, he cant stay up all nite going from room to room checking on everyone.still i think he would be a good choice, well respected with players and fans ,also was all this brought up to push him down the pecking order?jimbob17 wrote:The time is ticking away and the panel are at work trying to procure the new manager or management team. I think it is very important that this is done ASAP so that they can see the championship q finals and the finish of the championships to identify a panel to work with. Any ideas who are in the hunt or who should be in the shake up from inside or outside the county?? I am sure that approaches have been made to various people with regard to their interest as the selection panel are in place for a few weeks now. also who are the people that might make up a good management team, ie selectors etc.....
Tom Coffee has gone down the ranks in my opinion now with the shenanigans of the rhode players in Galway.....This is exactly the kind of thing that offaly needs to clean out to be reasonably competitive again... Any thoughts...
absolutely not on here to push anyone up or down any pecking order, just to discuss relevant issues. as you will see above, i reckon he is one of the favourites for the gig. however it is my personal opinion that it doesnt reflect well on him when news about a club he manages goes to galway and destroys rooms in a hotel and it gets plastered in the national newspapers. He is not responsible for messing things up down there obviously and the individuals should be made pay the price but he being manager has to take some form of responsibility his players behaviour.
If this were another county and something similar issue arose under a prospective county managers watch it wouldnt reflect well either. Given that issues around drink, personal discipline and general player behaviour will be a key issue around the selection of the next manager, is it not fair to assume that this does not reflect well. I do get the perception that you are possibly in Tom Coffees corner to get the job, and i dont mind that. However, from a neutral perspective, I am just making a point, and to answer your question bluntly, of course it puts him down the pecking order!!! To think otherwise, one would be a fool. that is not to say he wont get the job, or wont be part of a team that gets the job given the nature of the selection committee.
He deserves to be in the shake up, given what he has achieved with rhode in recent times, but club and county management are poles apart and there are others in the shake up who are not up to the job either in my opinion, not mentioning names. Tom Coffee walked in to an established set up after Steven Darby, and to my mind, have not progressed from that time. Darby did all the hard work and got them to a certain level, and walked away because he wouldnt tolerate what was going on out there. If anyone deserves the job from inside offaly, it is him. You may say that i am being biased, but i have never met the guy, and dont know him at all, but his record speaks for itself. He got that rhode team to their peak. Pat Flanagan has done consistently well over the past ten years and won numerous county championships with various adult club teams and would be right there in the mix except for being with the westies. outside that Phil Reilly and Noel O Brien are two obvious candidates, though i dont think the present selection comittee will consider O Brien or anyone outside their small circle of friends!!!!!